Why Italy Has Been Fighting Over Two Christmas Cakes for 100 Years

Sharing is caring!

Walk into any Italian home at Christmas and you will find two camps. Panettone on one side. Pandoro on the other. Ask someone which they prefer and they will answer as if you have asked about something deeply personal. Because, in Italy, you have.

A Tale of Two Cities

Panettone comes from Milan. Pandoro comes from Verona. That alone is enough to understand why this debate will never end.

Milan is confident, industrious, modern. Verona is romantic, ancient, proud. Both cities claim their Christmas cake is the real one. Neither will ever concede the point.

This is not just a cake debate. It is campanilismo — the deep Italian instinct to be fiercely loyal to your own town — expressed through butter and flour.

The Panettone Story

Panettone is the older of the two. The name likely comes from pan de toni — bread of Toni — though the exact origin story changes depending on who is telling it.

The Milanese version: a nobleman in love with a baker’s daughter, Toni, created the recipe to win her father’s favour. He sweetened the bread with candied fruit and eggs and presented it at Christmas. The baker was so impressed he hired the man and gave him his daughter’s hand.

Whether true or not, the story captures something real: panettone is the cake of effort, of patience, of love expressed through labour. The dough requires days of slow rising. A single rushed step collapses it entirely.

The dome-shaped panettone as we know it was perfected in the early 1900s. By mid-century, Milanese bakeries were sending it in ornate boxes across Italy and the world.

The Pandoro Story

Pandoro — golden bread — was officially registered in Verona in 1894 by baker Domenico Melegatti. It is a tall, star-shaped cake dusted with icing sugar, light and buttery, with no fruit inside.

That last point is not an oversight. It is a deliberate statement.

Pandoro fans will tell you that panettone’s candied citrus peel is an intrusion — a distraction from the pure sweetness of good butter and eggs. Panettone fans will reply that pandoro is bland, predictable, cowardly. These are strong words for a cake. This is Italy.

Enjoying this? 30,000 Italy lovers get stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

The Diaspora Dimension

For Italian families outside Italy, the debate carries extra weight. In cities like New York, Chicago, and Buenos Aires, immigrants brought their Christmas traditions with them.

The panettone box — tall, ribbon-tied, arriving at relatives’ doors each December — became a symbol of connection to the homeland. For many in the diaspora, the first time they tasted pandoro was on a trip back to Italy. Some converted. Most did not.

The debate crossed the Atlantic and never resolved there either. If anything, it hardened. In Italian-American families, the Christmas traditions brought from the old country tend to be defended with the same passion that was used to carry them in the first place.

The Numbers (and Why They Do Not Settle It)

Italy produces around 117 million panettoni and 50 million pandori each year. By sales volume, panettone wins clearly.

The pandoro side considers this a mark of commercial compromise, not cultural superiority. Panettone is easier to fill, easier to flavour, easier to market with chocolate cream or pistachio. Pandoro is classic. Pandoro is pure.

This logic is, depending on your camp, either admirably principled or completely absurd.

The One Thing Both Sides Agree On

Neither cake should be eaten after Christmas. This is one of the few points where panettone and pandoro fans will stand shoulder to shoulder.

The boxes that appear in supermarkets from October onwards are regarded with suspicion. Real panettone — from a proper Milanese pasticceria, arriving in a ribboned box — is something you wait for. It tastes better when the time is right. Both sides know this.

And there is one more thing they agree on, even if they would never admit it aloud: the debate itself is part of the pleasure. Choosing your side every December is as much a ritual as ordering your espresso the right way or knowing exactly when to sit down to eat.

Every December, the argument begins again. Families take sides. The same points are made. No one wins. No one is expected to. That is the Italian way with the things that matter most — you do not resolve them, you celebrate them, year after year, together.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Why Italians Feel More Loyalty to Their Town Than to Italy Itself
• Why Italian Children Get Their Gifts From a Witch, Not Santa Claus
• The Unwritten Rules of Italian Coffee That No One Tells Tourists

Plan Your Italy Trip

Ready to see Italy for yourself? Our Ultimate Italy Travel Guide covers everything from when to go to where to stay — written for travellers who want to experience Italy properly, not just pass through it.

Sharing is caring!