Little Italy: How Italian Immigrants Built Their Communities in America

Sharing is caring!

Your great-grandparents left a village in southern Italy. They crossed the Atlantic in steerage class. They arrived at Ellis Island with very little English and almost no money. And then they did something remarkable: they built a world.

Who Were the Italian Emigrants?

Between 1880 and 1924, more than four million Italians arrived in the United States. They came in waves. They came with very little. And most of them came from the same places.

Over 80 per cent of Italian immigrants arrived from the south: Sicily, Campania, Calabria, Basilicata, Puglia and Abruzzo. These were regions of grinding poverty. Farmland was controlled by absentee landlords. Taxes were heavy. Harvests failed. Young men looked at the boat tickets and decided to go.

They did not come to leave Italy behind. They came to earn enough money to return. Many planned to go home. Most did not.

The Journey to America

Leaving was not easy. Many families from Campania and Sicily walked for days to reach the port at Naples. They carried a single bag. Inside: a few clothes, perhaps a photograph, and — often — the seeds of a plant or a handful of soil from the family garden.

The crossing took two to three weeks in steerage class. Conditions were poor. Hundreds of people shared a single deck below the waterline. There was little light and less air. Many became ill. Some died at sea.

Then came Ellis Island.

Between 1892 and 1954, more than 12 million immigrants passed through its Great Hall. For Italian families arriving in the early 1900s, it was a place of fear and hope in equal measure. Inspectors checked eyes for trachoma. They asked questions. They wrote names into ledgers — sometimes changing the spelling, sometimes mishearing a Sicilian surname and writing something close enough.

If you want to find your own family’s arrival record, the Ellis Island Foundation database holds more than 65 million records. You can search by surname, year and ship. Many families have found the exact line where their great-great-grandparent was recorded, with the name of their home town listed alongside.

That town is where your family’s story begins in Italy. If you can read that record, you can find the village. And if you find the village, you can find the church records, the civil registers — your family, by name, going back generations. Our complete guide to tracing Italian ancestry walks you through every step.

The First Little Italies

When Italian immigrants arrived in American cities, they did not scatter. They clustered together. They found the street where someone from their village had already set up a room. They sent word home: venite qui — come here.

This is how Little Italy neighbourhoods were born — not as planned communities, but as chains of trust. A family from Palermo would rent rooms in a building where other Palermitani already lived. A family from Napoli would hear of work from a cousin’s cousin who had arrived six months earlier. Within a generation, entire blocks of New York’s Lower East Side, Boston’s North End or Chicago’s Near South Side had become almost entirely Italian in character.

The most famous Little Italy is in lower Manhattan. At its peak in the early 1900s, it covered dozens of streets and held more than 10,000 residents. Many had come from the same handful of Sicilian and Campanian towns. The Mulberry Street area was dominated by families from Sciacca and Palermo in Sicily. The blocks around Mott Street held communities from Naples.

Every September, the Feast of San Gennaro fills Mulberry Street. It has done so since 1926 — started by immigrants from Naples to honour their patron saint. San Gennaro is still celebrated in Naples every year, when the saint’s blood is said to liquefy in its vial. In New York, the feast became something more: a way for people who were now Americans to insist they were also still Italian.

How Communities Preserved What They Brought

Italian immigrants preserved their culture with remarkable determination. The things that mattered most — food, faith and family — were carried across the Atlantic and kept alive for generations.

🇮🇹 Enjoying this? 30,000 Italy lovers get stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

Sunday Sauce

Every Italian-American family has a Sunday sauce story. In some homes it is called gravy. In others, simply il ragù. But the ritual is the same: a large pot, started early, simmered for hours, filling the house with a smell that belongs to no country and every country at once.

The recipes for this sauce were not written down. They were passed hand to hand, mother to daughter, grandmother to granddaughter. They crossed the Atlantic inside someone’s memory. When Calabrian families arrived in New York or Chicago, they made their sauce with the pork and tomatoes they could find — not identical to what they had in Cosenza or Reggio, but close enough to remember.

Many Italian-American families today can trace their Sunday sauce recipe to a specific region of Italy. The spicing in a Sicilian-American ragù differs from that of a Neapolitan-American one. These differences are invisible unless you know to look. But for people tracing their heritage, they are a thread back to a place.

The Church

The Catholic church was the centre of every Little Italy neighbourhood. Italian immigrants often found that Irish-American Catholic parishes did not welcome them. They founded their own. By 1900, dozens of Italian national parishes operated across New York, Boston, Philadelphia and Chicago.

These churches became social institutions. They ran schools, organised mutual aid societies and hosted the feast days that kept regional Italian identities alive. In New York, Italian communities from different regions built their own chapels: the Neapolitans had their San Gennaro, the Sicilians had Our Lady of Loreto, the Calabrians had their own shrines.

If your Italian family was Catholic — and most were — the parish records of these national churches are a remarkable genealogical resource. Many have been microfilmed by the FamilySearch database. You can sometimes find baptism records for your great-grandparents, recorded by a priest who had also known them in Italy.

The Naming Tradition

Italian families in America kept to a naming tradition that had been followed in Italy for centuries. The first son was named after the paternal grandfather. The second son after the maternal grandfather. The first daughter after the paternal grandmother. The second daughter after the maternal grandmother.

This cycle was so consistent that genealogists use it as a research tool. If your grandfather was called Giuseppe, his father was almost certainly called Giuseppe too — and possibly his grandfather before that. If you know the name pattern in your American family, you can predict the names you will find when you search Italian civil records going back to the 1860s. Our article on Italian naming traditions explains this cycle in detail.

Language

Italian immigrants spoke the dialect of their region, not standard Italian. A family from Palermo spoke Sicilian. A family from Naples spoke Neapolitan. These are distinct languages in many respects — not just accents.

In Little Italy neighbourhoods, this meant that the block where your family lived often determined what language you spoke at home. Neapolitan families could not always understand Sicilian families, even though they were neighbours. Over time, a form of Italian-American dialect developed: a mix of regional Italian, American English, and words invented to describe things that had no Italian name.

Some of these words survived into the third and fourth generation. Words like mangiare for eating, capisce for understanding, abbraccio for a hug. They appear in Italian-American families who no longer speak Italian at all — fragments of language that crossed the Atlantic and stayed.

The Cities That Shaped Italian America

Every major American city with an Italian community has its own story. Here are some of the most significant.

New York City

New York received more Italian immigrants than any other American city. By 1910, more than 340,000 Italians lived in Manhattan alone. The Lower East Side’s Little Italy was the largest concentration, but Italian communities also formed in East Harlem (known as Italian Harlem until the 1950s), Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens, and the Bronx.

Today, the original Lower Manhattan Little Italy has shrunk to a few blocks of Mulberry Street. Chinatown expanded to absorb much of the old neighbourhood. But the Feast of San Gennaro continues. The restaurants on Mulberry Street still serve the dishes that were carried from Naples and Sicily in the 1900s.

Boston’s North End

Boston’s North End was an Irish neighbourhood before it was Italian. By the 1880s, it had become predominantly Italian — and it remained so for nearly a century. Today the North End is still the heart of Italian-American Boston.

The Feast of the Assumption, held every August, transforms the neighbourhood for weeks. Processions carry the statue of the Madonna through the streets while bands play and fireworks light the harbour. This feast was brought from the Sicilian town of Sciacca, where it has been celebrated for centuries. In Boston, it has continued for over 100 years.

Chicago’s Near South Side

Chicago’s Italian community settled along Taylor Street on the Near South Side, creating one of the largest Little Italies in America by the early 1900s. It drew immigrants from Sicily, Campania, and Calabria. Many worked in the meatpacking yards and stockyards of the city.

Much of the original neighbourhood was demolished for urban renewal projects in the 1960s. But the Taylor Street area still holds Italian restaurants, delicatessens and bakeries. The memory of the neighbourhood is kept alive by the Italian-American community that spread from it into the wider Chicago suburbs.

San Francisco’s North Beach

San Francisco’s Italian community centred on North Beach, drawing immigrants primarily from Genoa and Sicily. Genoese fishermen were among the earliest Italian settlers in the city. By the early 1900s, the neighbourhood had become a distinct Italian community with its own churches, restaurants and social clubs.

North Beach today retains much of its Italian character. Washington Square Park is surrounded by Italian restaurants and cafés. The area’s history includes early Italian-American success stories: the DiMaggio family, including baseball legend Joe DiMaggio, came from a Sicilian fishing family that settled in the area. The Bank of America was founded by Amadeo Giannini, son of Genoese immigrants, who recognised that Italian-Americans had no bank willing to lend to them.

Philadelphia’s South Philly

South Philadelphia drew large numbers of Italian immigrants from Abruzzo, Campania and Sicily. The Italian Market on 9th Street — established in the late 1800s — still operates today, selling produce, cheese, meat and fish in a tradition that has continued for over a century. It is one of the oldest and largest outdoor markets in the United States.

The Decline of Little Italy — and What Survived

By the mid-twentieth century, Little Italy neighbourhoods began to change. The children of immigrants moved to the suburbs. Urban renewal programmes demolished housing. Other immigrant communities moved in. The dense, insular Italian neighbourhoods of the early 1900s dispersed.

What survived was culture rather than geography. The Italian-American family structure — its emphasis on la famiglia, on Sunday dinners, on loyalty to kin — moved to the suburbs and stayed. The food moved too. The recipes for Sunday sauce, for cannoli, for braciole and struffoli, were carried from the tenements of Mulberry Street to the kitchens of New Jersey and Connecticut.

The feast days moved. San Gennaro now draws hundreds of thousands of visitors to Mulberry Street every September — more visitors than lived in the original neighbourhood. Italian-American feast days continue in cities across the country, often organised by third- and fourth-generation descendants who have never been to Italy.

And the stories survived. Italian-American families hold their family histories with unusual intensity. Many know the name of the town their great-grandparents came from. Many have the photograph that was carried in the immigration bag. Many have the Sunday sauce recipe in a grandmother’s handwriting.

Connecting with Your Italian Roots Today

If you are an Italian-American reading this, your family’s story reaches back to a specific village in southern Italy. That village has civil records going back to the 1860s. It has church records going back further. It has a piazza, a fountain, a church — and possibly distant relatives who share your surname.

Here is how to start connecting:

Find the town: The starting point is usually a document — a death certificate, an Ellis Island record, a naturalisation paper. These often list the town of birth. Our guide to finding your Italian ancestral village walks through each source step by step.

Search the records: Once you have the town, the Antenati portal provides free access to millions of Italian civil records. Births, marriages and deaths from 1866 onwards are searchable for most comuni. Our guide to Italian civil records shows you how to read them.

Search before 1866: For earlier generations, Italian parish records are the source. Many have been microfilmed and are available through FamilySearch.

Find living relatives: DNA testing, Facebook groups, and writing to the comune are all paths to connecting with relatives still in Italy. Our guide on finding Italian relatives covers each method.

Visit the village: There is nothing quite like standing in the piazza where your great-grandparents met. Our heritage trip planning guide covers everything you need to organise the visit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which parts of Italy did most Italian-Americans come from?

Over 80 per cent of Italian immigrants to the United States came from the south: Sicily, Campania, Calabria, Basilicata, Puglia and Abruzzo. These were the poorest regions of Italy in the late 1800s and early 1900s, and emigration was driven primarily by poverty and lack of opportunity.

When did most Italian immigrants arrive in America?

The peak years of Italian immigration were 1880 to 1924. The Immigration Act of 1924 introduced strict national quotas that sharply reduced immigration from southern and eastern Europe. Before 1924, more than four million Italians had arrived in the United States, with the highest numbers arriving between 1900 and 1910.

Why did Italian immigrants stay in the same neighbourhoods?

Chain migration kept Italian immigrants clustered together. An immigrant from a particular town would write home with news of jobs and affordable rooms. Friends and family from the same village would follow. This created neighbourhoods where people from the same town, speaking the same dialect, lived and worked side by side. It was a practical survival strategy in an unfamiliar country.

How can I find out which Italian town my ancestors came from?

Start with American documents: death certificates, census records, naturalisation papers and Ellis Island passenger records often list the town of origin. The Ellis Island database and the Ancestry.com records are searchable by name and year. Our full guide to finding your Italian ancestral village covers each source in detail.

Is the Italian-American naming tradition still used today?

The traditional cycle — first son named after paternal grandfather, first daughter after paternal grandmother — was common in Italian-American families through the mid-twentieth century. It is less universal today, but many families still follow it. If your family kept the tradition, it can be a powerful genealogical tool: the pattern of names in your American family will likely mirror the names in your Italian family records.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Why Your Italian Ancestors Left Italy: The Story of the Great Emigration
• Italian Immigration Records: How to Find Your Ancestors at Ellis Island and Beyond
• How to Plan an Italian Heritage Trip to Your Ancestral Town

Know someone who loves Italy or Italian heritage? Forward this to them — it’s completely free to read and subscribe at lovetovisititaly.substack.com.

Plan Your Italy Trip: Ready to visit the country your ancestors left behind? Our ultimate Italy travel guide has everything you need to plan an unforgettable trip.

Sharing is caring!