The Italian Christmas Debate That Divides Every Family: Panettone or Pandoro?

Sharing is caring!

Every December, Italy wages a delicious war. It happens in kitchens, at office parties, and around every Christmas table. The question is simple: panettone or pandoro?

The answer, for most Italians, is anything but simple.

Two Cakes, One Very Old Argument

Italians are fiercely proud of their regional food. But this debate crosses every region, every generation, and every Christmas table. It has been running for over a century, and nobody is close to winning.

Panettone is the dome-shaped bread from Milan, studded with candied fruit and raisins. Pandoro is the golden star-shaped cake from Verona, dusted in vanilla icing sugar. They share a season but almost nothing else.

The Italian word for the rivalry is scontro — a clash. And every December, it renews itself louder than the year before.

What Makes Panettone, Panettone

True panettone is not a cake. It is a leavened bread that takes up to three days to make. The dough rises slowly, absorbs butter and eggs in careful stages, and emerges tall and fragrant with vanilla and orange zest.

Inside, you find candied citrus peel and plump raisins — though modern versions also pack in chocolate chips, cream, or pistachio. Every bakery in Milan has its own recipe. Every nonna has an opinion on whose is best.

The word “panettone” roughly means “big loaf”, and the origin stories are wonderfully dramatic. One legend involves a young baker named Toni who accidentally dropped candied peel into bread dough and presented it as intentional. Another credits a duke, a baker, and a love affair. The most likely truth? It evolved slowly in Milanese monasteries over the 15th century, eventually becoming the city’s defining Christmas food.

If you want to understand Italian food culture beyond the tourist trail, the secret behind Italian nonna cooking reveals exactly why recipes like this survive for centuries — passed down not in books but through taste and memory.

The Pandoro Defence

Pandoro fans will tell you that panettone is too chewy, too dense, and that nobody actually enjoys the candied peel. They have a point about the peel — even in Italy, it divides opinion.

Pandoro, by contrast, is soft, buttery, and uncomplicated. It comes in a star-shaped mould, dusted with a cloud of vanilla icing sugar that you shake on yourself from a little bag inside the box. That moment — tearing open the packaging, shaking on the sugar, breathing in warm vanilla — is genuinely joyful.

Pandoro was first registered by Domenico Melegatti in Verona in 1894. Its name means “golden bread”, and the colour lives up to it: a rich, egg-yolk yellow. It tastes like the most indulgent brioche you have ever eaten.

Enjoying this? 29,000+ Italy lovers get stories like this every week. Subscribe free

The Battle Goes to the Supermarkets

For most of Italy’s history, both were made at home or bought from a local bakery. Then the industrial food companies arrived, and everything changed.

Today, Motta, Bauli, and Balocco produce millions of units every December. Supermarkets stack them in towers near the entrance from October onwards. You can buy a decent one for under five euros, or a handmade artisan version for fifty.

The industrial versions are acceptable. But if you ever taste a proper artisan panettone from a Milanese pasticceria — the kind that takes three days to make and arrives in a silk ribbon box — you will understand why this argument still matters. Real panettone cannot be rushed. The same is true of pandoro made the old way, with proper lievito madre (natural yeast) and slow fermentation.

Italy’s coffee bar culture tells a similar story — the espresso bar ritual only makes sense once you understand that Italians treat food and drink as living traditions, not just consumption.

So Who Actually Wins?

Sales figures say panettone. It outsells pandoro roughly two to one in Italy, every single year. The market has been consistent for decades.

But pandoro fans argue that market share proves nothing. They say panettone dominates because it has been sold more aggressively, exported more widely, and marketed more cleverly. They are probably right about all three.

What both sides agree on: the best version of whichever you prefer, made properly with real ingredients and time, is worth hunting down. And worth sharing.

There is one rule both sides observe, without negotiation. You do not eat either one until December. Starting in October — as some shops now do — is considered borderline criminal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between panettone and pandoro?

Panettone is a Milanese leavened bread studded with candied fruit and raisins, with a distinctive dome shape. Pandoro is a Veronese buttery cake shaped like a star and dusted in vanilla icing sugar. Both are eaten across Italy during Christmas and Epiphany.

Which is more popular in Italy, panettone or pandoro?

Panettone outsells pandoro roughly two to one in Italy each December. However, pandoro has a fiercely loyal following, particularly in northern Italy, and the debate between the two is renewed every Christmas season.

Where can I buy the best panettone in Italy?

The finest panettone comes from artisan pasticcerie in Milan. Look for those using lievito madre (natural yeast) and a slow three-day fermentation process. Expect to pay between 25 and 50 euros for a proper handmade version — the difference from supermarket brands is remarkable.

When do Italians eat panettone and pandoro?

Both are strictly Christmas foods in Italy, served from December through to Epiphany on 6th January. Starting earlier — as some supermarkets do from October — is widely frowned upon by Italians who prefer to keep the tradition intact.

Italy’s Christmas debate has no winner. It never will. And that is exactly the point.

What it does have is two extraordinary foods, each born from centuries of craft, regional pride, and stubbornness. Wherever you sit in the argument, the only thing that matters is that you try the real version — made slowly, with good ingredients, in a proper Italian pasticceria.

That first bite will settle the debate for you. At least until next December.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Why Italian Nonnas Never Measure Anything
• Why the Italian Coffee Bar Is the Key to Understanding Italian Life
• Why Real Pesto from Genoa Tastes Nothing Like What You’ve Been Eating

Plan Your Italy Trip

Ready to experience Italian food culture firsthand? Our ultimate Italy travel guide covers everything you need to plan an unforgettable trip — from the best regions to visit to when to go and what to eat.

Sharing is caring!