Why Every Italian Region Thinks Its Focaccia Is the Only Real One

Sharing is caring!

Walk into a bakery in Genoa at seven in the morning and you will find locals tearing off warm slabs of flat, olive-oil-soaked bread before the city has properly woken up. Drive four hours south to Bari and ask for focaccia — what arrives will look nothing like what you had in Genoa. Ask in Rome and they will hand you something else entirely, and insist it’s not even the same bread at all.

This is focaccia. Italy’s most argued-about bread. And the argument has been going on since ancient Rome.

Where It All Began: Liguria and the Fugassa

In Liguria, they call it fugassa. It has been made here for thousands of years — the ancient Romans baked a nearly identical flatbread called panis focacius, cooked directly on the hearth. The word focaccia comes from the Latin for fire.

The Genoese version is about two centimetres thick, dimpled across the surface, drizzled with olive oil, and scattered with coarse sea salt. That is it. No toppings. No embellishments. The quality of the oil does all the talking.

What surprises most visitors is when they see locals eating it with their morning cappuccino — not alongside it, but dipped into it. The warm bread soaks up the milky coffee and becomes something Ligurians consider entirely natural. Every neighbourhood has its preferred bakery. Debates about whose is better have lasted generations.

The Version With Cheese Inside — and Its Own Protected Status

Twenty kilometres east of Genoa lies the village of Recco. Here, the focaccia contains no yeast and looks nothing like the Ligurian original.

Focaccia di Recco col Formaggio is two layers of paper-thin dough stretched around fresh stracchino cheese. Baked at high heat, the outside blisters and crisps while the inside melts into a molten, tangy filling. Nothing else goes in. No herbs, no olive oil on top, no decoration.

It holds Protected Geographical Indication status, meaning authentic Focaccia di Recco can only be made in a handful of municipalities around the village. Producers elsewhere cannot legally use the name. When Italians from other regions try it for the first time, many refuse to call it focaccia at all. In Recco, they take that as a compliment.

The Pugliese Version That Makes No Apologies

In Puglia, focaccia is thick, puffy, and buried under cherry tomatoes, black olives, and a pool of olive oil that makes no apology for its generosity. The dough is made with semolina rather than soft wheat, giving it a golden colour and a slight crunch at the base.

In Bari, you can buy it warm from street-side counters throughout the day. The tomatoes are pressed into the dough before baking so they burst and caramelise at the edges. It bears almost no resemblance to the Ligurian original — different flour, different toppings, different texture entirely.

Ask a Pugliese baker if it’s really the same bread as the Genoese version and they will look at you as though you’ve asked an absurd question. Of course it is. It’s focaccia. Theirs. And the food traditions of Bari run deep — making and sharing food in public is something Pugliese communities have done for centuries.

Enjoying this? 30,000 Italy lovers get stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

Rome Calls It Something Else — and Considers the Discussion Closed

In Rome, the equivalent flatbread is called pizza bianca — white pizza. It is thinner than the Ligurian version, slightly crispier, and eaten throughout the day: stuffed with mortadella as a lunchtime sandwich, torn into pieces alongside a meal, or eaten plain as a mid-morning snack.

Romans do not consider it the same as focaccia. Focaccia, in their view, is something from the north. Pizza bianca is Roman. The distinction matters and they will make sure you understand it.

Ask a Roman baker which is better — the Ligurian focaccia or the pizza bianca — and the answer will come without hesitation. The Roman one. Obviously.

Sicily’s Version Isn’t Even Called Focaccia

In Palermo, the local flatbread is called sfincione. It is thick and spongy, topped with tomato sauce, onions, anchovy, and a generous grating of caciocavallo cheese. Street vendors sell it from wheeled carts, shouting their prices to passers-by.

Palermitans do not call it focaccia. But if you described the concept — a leavened, flat, baked dough eaten as a snack or with meals — they would recognise it immediately as the same ancient idea, adapted entirely to what their corner of Italy had available.

Why Every Region Is Completely Right

Italy was not unified as a nation until 1861. For centuries before that, each region, each city, each valley had its own economy, its own dialect, and its own food. What people baked depended on the grain they grew, the fat they pressed, and the wood that fuelled their ovens.

The differences in focaccia are not random. They are a record of how communities lived. Ligurian fugassa reflects a maritime culture where olive oil was currency. Pugliese focaccia reflects the flat semolina plains and ancient olive groves of the south. Recco’s cheese version reflects the mountain dairies above the Ligurian coast. The same principle explains why Italy has hundreds of different pasta shapes — each one tied to the hands and traditions of a specific place.

When an Italian defends their version of focaccia, they are not just talking about bread. They are talking about identity. About their grandmother’s kitchen. About the bakery they walked past on the way to school.

That is why no one will ever agree. And that, in its own way, is exactly what makes Italian food so extraordinary to discover.

You Might Also Enjoy

• The Real Reason Italy Has a Different Pasta Shape for Every Region
• Why Real Pesto From Genoa Tastes Nothing Like What You’ve Been Eating
• The Bari Grandmothers Who Have Made Pasta in the Street for 200 Years

Plan Your Italy Trip

Ready to taste these traditions for yourself? Our complete Italy travel guide covers everything from planning your itinerary to finding the best regional food experiences across the country.

Sharing is caring!